More over by its resolution court of appeal also dismissed appeals LLC KUA "Svarog Esset Management" and Belinskiy A.E.
Company "Svarog Esset Management" and Belinskiy А.Е. for this case were the third parties with own requirements for considering as invalid stockholder registration and resolution of general stockholder meeting OJSC "Turboatom" dated 28.08.2007.
In October 2007 in behalf of CCU Prosecutor General of Ukraine (PGU) appeal to Economic Court of Kharkov Region with claim to consider resolution of general stockholder meeting dated 28.08.2007 as invalid based on that power of attorney of person represented the state on stockholder meeting was arranged not properly.
16 April 2008 Economic Court of Kharkov Region rejected CCU in satisfaction of claims in full scope. This position later was confirmed by resolution of Kharkov Appeal Economic Court and Highest Economic Court of Ukraine.
However 17 February 2009 Supreme Court of Ukraine review cassation of PGU, cancelled resolution of inferior degree of jurisdiction and send case for new review to court of original jurisdiction, consider as premature resolutions of inferior degree of jurisdiction.
31 March 2009 Prosecutor General submitted notification about rejection of claim, which was accepted by court. But consider that during hole process of this case directly CCU submitted no explanation per se of plaintiff's claim, court considered as reasonable to proceed with further review of given claims.
15 July 2009 Economic Court of Kharkov Region rejected satisfaction of abovementioned claims in full scope.